Its very easy to make a chunky dent in the achievements for this game, some can be done right in the opening moments (Legends - "Cronch", What Shall We Do with a Drunken Sailor?), and some more soon after setting sail for the first time (Handbrake Turn, Full Billow and others).
There's a chunk of grinding to do (yay), inevitably for a live service MMO-ish type of game. As a fully open-world sandbox there isn't really a campaign as such - so in the guide here we have defined 'Story' as 'do everything for the three trading companies and become a Pirate Legend (Become Pirate Legend), plus the original sequence of Tall Tales.
The grind achievements are a grind, but they are unlocked as a consequence of getting commendations (i.e. unlocked at various points in the grind), so progress toward them isn't reported in the same way as a normal 'get X kills' type achievement. The achievements are all for the Grade 5 (highest) level for the category. These will take a good while to unlock them all - albeit with good use of Emissary flags to boost gold/XP its nowhere near as painful as it was at launch.
Nothing is missable and there's no difficulty setting - just set sail and enjoy!
But many achievements are Unobtainable; as they relate to the old Arena mode that was removed in a previous update. There is no way to get these and no chance of this ever being reinstated.
Note; this is an online-only shared-world game. Most of it you can solo, but some achievements require that you engage with other players, including Dead Pirates DO Tell Tales, Did Everyone See That?, Friends Not Foe, Legends - "The Greatest Race of All Time!", Legends - "This is Unacceptable!", Legends - "The Skullduggers", Tactical Chunder, I'm On A Whole New Adventure, and maybe Ignoring The Rules Of Engagement, How Appropriate! You Fight Like A Chicken and You Fight Like A Merchant as well.
It is highly recommended that you use microphone to contact other players, this is a great way to boost up achievements that require you to act as friends or foes. Also the LFG channels in the Sea of Thieves Discord are a great place to find people to sail with, for the achievements and also for general progress.
You ate a banana, skin and all.
You ate a banana, skin and all.
You can get this right at the beginning of the game in the tavern - select the banana from your inventory and eat it...
You set sail for the first time.
You set sail for the first time.
Your reputation level with a Trading Company increased for the first time.
Your reputation level with a Trading Company increased for the first time.
You changed course by dropping anchor while the ship's wheel was at full lock.
You changed course by dropping anchor while the ship's wheel was at full lock.
You vomited for the first time.
You vomited for the first time.
(Adventure) You became sick from undercooked food.
(Adventure) You became sick from undercooked food.
Eat raw/uncooked food and be sick. This is easy right from the beginning with any meat. Kill a chicken/snake/pig on any island to get meat if needed.
You killed a skeleton while it was 'cronching' on a banana.
You killed a skeleton while it was 'cronching' on a banana.
Cronch means eat. Skeletons may eat a banana to heal if they are injured. Kill one quick while it is doing this. This was partially glitched back at launch but works fine more recently.
You earned ten Commendations.
You earned ten Commendations.
You voted for and began a voyage put forward by one of your crew.
You voted for and began a voyage put forward by one of your crew.
You took part in the sinking of another crew's ship.
You took part in the sinking of another crew's ship.
You sailed with all sails fully with the wind.
You sailed with all sails fully with the wind.
You completed a Gold Hoarder voyage.
You completed a Gold Hoarder voyage.
Gold Hoarders are one of the three factions you'll do missions for. These are the ones in the small tent with the gold key flag outside and a wizened dude inside.
The missions will be to find an island with an 'X' marks the spot, where there'll be a buried chest. Find the island and dig up the treasure to complete the mission. On completing the first one you'll likely unlock I Wanna Be A Pirate! as well.
You purchased your first Trading Company Promotion.
You purchased your first Trading Company Promotion.
You completed the Maiden Voyage
You completed the Maiden Voyage
Play the Tutorial, press 1 on PC to start the Maiden Voyage in the title screen, press X on Xbox
You burned a piece of food.
You burned a piece of food.
You can cook food on a stove on your ship. Leave something on the stove for 5 minutes or so and it'll burn. Don't leave it too long or your ship will catch fire...
You've eaten at least one piece of every kind of fruit.
You've eaten at least one piece of every kind of fruit.
You can scavenge all kinds from barrels on outpost islands.
Another crew took one of your chests and cashed it in.
Another crew took one of your chests and cashed it in.
You completed an Order of Souls Voyage.
You completed an Order of Souls Voyage.
See It's A Pirates Life For Me, but for the Order of Souls you have to go to an island, kill skeletons and bring back their skulls.
(Adventure) As an Emissary of the Gold Hoarders, your greed knows no limits or borders.
(Adventure) As an Emissary of the Gold Hoarders, your greed knows no limits or borders.
When you spawn in an outpost, go to the Gold Hoarders Tent and vote to raise an Emissary Flag.
You purchased a new ship customisation from the Shipwright.
You purchased a new ship customisation from the Shipwright.
You purchased a new Eye of Reach from a Weaponsmith.
You purchased a new Eye of Reach from a Weaponsmith.
You purchased a new blunderbuss from the Weaponsmith.
You purchased a new blunderbuss from the Weaponsmith.
You have become a Reaper's Bones Emissary; now your foes find you even more scary.
You have become a Reaper's Bones Emissary; now your foes find you even more scary.
You must first be level 15 for the faction, and then buy the emissary flag for 20,000 gold from their representative at any outpost. Then (in the same room/area as the representative) vote to be emissary on the nearby table.
This will unlock if you're in a crew and you only vote - i.e. even if you're under lvl 15 and someone else buys the flag.
Conversely - you can also do this solo; just buy the flag and vote solo to raise it.
NB being an emissary increases XP gains significantly - helping with other achievement grinds.
Set sail in the Order of Souls' name and gathering skulls will boost your fame.
Set sail in the Order of Souls' name and gathering skulls will boost your fame.
You must first be level 15 for the faction, and then buy the emissary flag for 20,000 gold from their representative at any outpost. Then (in the same room/area as the representative) vote to be emissary on the nearby table.
This will unlock if you're in a crew and you only vote - i.e. even if you're under lvl 15 and someone else buys the flag.
Conversely - you can also do this solo; just buy the flag and vote solo to raise it.
NB being an emissary increases XP gains significantly - helping with other achievement grinds.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for earning 150,000 gold from Gold Hoarder voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for earning 150,000 gold from Gold Hoarder voyages.
Grind this Gold Hoarder commendation to level 5.
You purchased the Promotion at Reputation Level 25 in any Trading Company.
You purchased the Promotion at Reputation Level 25 in any Trading Company.
You killed an opponent from behind with a blunderbuss.
You killed an opponent from behind with a blunderbuss.
You own ten Pirate Titles.
You own ten Pirate Titles.
You had an attack blocked by an opponent, and were hit by them within five seconds.
You had an attack blocked by an opponent, and were hit by them within five seconds.
You were victorious in a Kraken encounter and lived to tell the tale!
You were victorious in a Kraken encounter and lived to tell the tale!
The kraken appears randomly as you sail around; it could spawn could happen anytime while at sea, to a single ship. There is no way to trigger it (nor avoid it) - except that it cannot appear at the same time as another world event. It is defeatable easily with a single ship - just keep hitting the tentacles with cannonfire until it retreats.
Avoid being grabbed by a tentacle and lifted off the ship - if you're solo this is the most likely way to end up sunk and fail.
(Adventure) You had twenty chests in your crew's possession... at the same time!
(Adventure) You had twenty chests in your crew's possession... at the same time!
Yeah, loot lots before turning in, and pray nobody takes you out. Easiest when working together for the achievement with 4 players on a galleon.
Use the Gold Hoarders' Ancient Vault quests - for 8 or so chests at a time.
Note the chests don't actually have to be on your ship - just in your "possession"; so just picking a chest up counts as making it yours.
You completed 'A Pirate's Life'.
You completed 'A Pirate's Life'.
This is a Tall Tale mission that can be started from a character at a campfire at any outpost. Its the first in the sequence of Tall Tales in the Pirates of the Caribbean crossover.
The Merchant Alliance you now represent, never forget your extra percent.
The Merchant Alliance you now represent, never forget your extra percent.
You must first be level 15 for the faction, and then buy the emissary flag for 20,000 gold from their representative at any outpost. Then (in the same room/area as the representative) vote to be emissary on the nearby table.
This will unlock if you're in a crew and you only vote - i.e. even if you're under lvl 15 and someone else buys the flag.
Conversely - you can also do this solo; just buy the flag and vote solo to raise it.
NB being an emissary increases XP gains significantly - helping with other achievement grinds.
Received the Commendation for earning 150,000 gold from Order of Souls Voyages.
Received the Commendation for earning 150,000 gold from Order of Souls Voyages.
You cashed in a stolen Captain's Chest.
You cashed in a stolen Captain's Chest.
You completed a Merchant Alliance voyage.
You completed a Merchant Alliance voyage.
(Adventure) Completed 'The Shroudbreaker' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Completed 'The Shroudbreaker' Tall Tale.
At every outpost you can vote on this Tall Tale at the mysterious Stranger in the Tavern
You sold the Tome of Resurrection I.
You sold the Tome of Resurrection I.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Resurrection II.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Resurrection II.
You sold the Tome of Resurrection III.
You sold the Tome of Resurrection III.
You sold the Tome of Resurrection IV.
You sold the Tome of Resurrection IV.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Resurrection V.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Resurrection V.
You blocked a melee attack, then struck your opponent within five seconds.
You blocked a melee attack, then struck your opponent within five seconds.
You purchased a new hook, peg-leg, eyepatch, and hat from the Clothing Shop.
You purchased a new hook, peg-leg, eyepatch, and hat from the Clothing Shop.
you'll want about 40,000 gold to be able to buy all four items.
You gave your ship a Captain's send-off by playing a song aboard it while it sank.
You gave your ship a Captain's send-off by playing a song aboard it while it sank.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Curses III.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Curses III.
You sold the Tome of Curses II.
You sold the Tome of Curses II.
You sold the Tome of Curses I.
You sold the Tome of Curses I.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Curses V.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Curses V.
You sold the Tome of Curses IV.
You sold the Tome of Curses IV.
Received the Commendation for earning 150,000 gold from Merchant Alliance Voyages.
Received the Commendation for earning 150,000 gold from Merchant Alliance Voyages.
(Adventure) For Athena's Fortune a Legend can sail, an Emissary of those who prevail.
(Adventure) For Athena's Fortune a Legend can sail, an Emissary of those who prevail.
NB Athena's Fortune only becomes accessible once you're a Pirate Legend.
There is no level requirement to buy the flag for Athene's fortune. Then (in the same room/area as the representative) vote to be emissary on the nearby table.
This will unlock if you're in a crew and you only vote - i.e. even if you're under lvl 15 and someone else buys the flag.
Conversely - you can also do this solo; just buy the flag and vote solo to raise it.
NB being an emissary increases XP gains significantly - helping with other achievement grinds.
(Adventure) You cleared the Fort of the Damned of all enemies.
(Adventure) You cleared the Fort of the Damned of all enemies.
Some Vault Key hunters need a map, but you struck gold with just a scrap.
Some Vault Key hunters need a map, but you struck gold with just a scrap.
Delivered a luminescent fish to The Hunter's Call.
Delivered a luminescent fish to The Hunter's Call.
Sell a night Fish at the hunters Call, you can steal or fish one.
You completed 'The Sunken Pearl'.
You completed 'The Sunken Pearl'.
You sold the Tome of Fire V.
You sold the Tome of Fire V.
You sold the Tome of Fire II.
You sold the Tome of Fire II.
You sold the Tome of Fire I.
You sold the Tome of Fire I.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Fire III.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Fire III.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Fire IV.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Fire IV.
You sold the Tome of Power I.
You sold the Tome of Power I.
(Adventure) You woke the Fort of the Damned and stared death in the face!
(Adventure) You woke the Fort of the Damned and stared death in the face!
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Power II.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Power II.
Completed 'The Cursed Rogue' Tall Tale.
Completed 'The Cursed Rogue' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Power IV.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Power IV.
You sold the Tome of Power V.
You sold the Tome of Power V.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Power III.
(Adventure) You sold the Tome of Power III.
(Adventure) You defeated each colour of Shadow of Fate.
(Adventure) You defeated each colour of Shadow of Fate.
At the Fort of the Damned kill a skeleton of every Color.
(Adventure) You completed Heart of Fire
(Adventure) You completed Heart of Fire
Complete this Tall Tale
Used Pirate Chat to communicate with another dead pirate on the Ferry of the Damned.
Used Pirate Chat to communicate with another dead pirate on the Ferry of the Damned.
(Adventure) You purchased the 'Master Gold Hoarder' Promotion in the Gold Hoarder Trading Company.
(Adventure) You purchased the 'Master Gold Hoarder' Promotion in the Gold Hoarder Trading Company.
You have to reach level 50 with the Gold Hoarders to get this. It would be a Grind type achievement except that you need this anyway for Become Pirate Legend
(Adventure) You cooked a piece of food on a campfire at night.
(Adventure) You cooked a piece of food on a campfire at night.
This is easy to do anytime - there are campfires on all the outposts, and fruit available in the barrels dotted around the place. Just wait until nightfall, equip some fruit, and interact with the campfire to cook it.
You completed The Seabound Soul
You completed The Seabound Soul
Complete this Tall Tale
You launched yourself from a ship's cannon onto a ship.
You launched yourself from a ship's cannon onto a ship.
You located the missing ship on a Lost Shipment Voyage without finding all the clues.
You located the missing ship on a Lost Shipment Voyage without finding all the clues.
You completed 'Captains of the Damned'.
You completed 'Captains of the Damned'.
You played the same shanty in a band of five Pirates.
You played the same shanty in a band of five Pirates.
What it says on the tin; stand in a group of 5 players and all play a musical instrument at the same time.
But, the bit that makes this harder is 5 players, and there's a max of 4 on your ship. So you need to be lucky with a friendly crew at an outpost, or in an alliance with one. Chat/voice comms to request everyone goes to the tavern for the achievement definitely helps.
(Adventure) From a vault you took every piece of gold, yet the clink of coins never gets old.
(Adventure) From a vault you took every piece of gold, yet the clink of coins never gets old.
(Adventure) You sold all 5 Tomes of Resurrection.
(Adventure) You sold all 5 Tomes of Resurrection.
You enjoyed a tankard of grog with another crew at an Outpost.
You enjoyed a tankard of grog with another crew at an Outpost.
(Adventure) You purchased the 'Master of the Order' Promotion in the Order of Souls Trading Company.
(Adventure) You purchased the 'Master of the Order' Promotion in the Order of Souls Trading Company.
You have to reach level 50 to get this. It would be a Grind type achievement except that you need this anyway for Become Pirate Legend
You performed the Pirate Salute gesture to befriend someone in-game.
You performed the Pirate Salute gesture to befriend someone in-game.
(Adventure) You upgraded a Trading Company item to its maximum.
(Adventure) You upgraded a Trading Company item to its maximum.
Another painful grind; you can do this for any of the items that the trading companies sell you (each one has two items you can buy). the max level upgrade only becomes available when you're at rank 45 with the trading company, and it will cost a total of 15,000 gold to buy through the upgrades.
You've opened the greatest Treasure Vaults, the occasional deaths were not your fault.
You've opened the greatest Treasure Vaults, the occasional deaths were not your fault.
Delivered a rare coloured fish to The Hunter's Call.
Delivered a rare coloured fish to The Hunter's Call.
You completed 'Dark Brethren'.
You completed 'Dark Brethren'.
(Adventure) You became a Pirate Legend!
(Adventure) You became a Pirate Legend!
Becoming a Pirate Legend is effectively the endgame of the game at launch, but the beginning of the next stage in another sense.
You become a Pirate Legend after grinding to level 50 with all three trading companies. This will take a looonnngg time!
Completed 'The Legendary Storyteller' Tall Tale.
Completed 'The Legendary Storyteller' Tall Tale.
Complete the "the Legendary Storyteller" tall tail. The book to start this is given by Tasha in the tavern at the Ancient Spire Outpost.
You found and sold at least one of each Legendary Treasure.
You found and sold at least one of each Legendary Treasure.
You have to be a Pirate Legend first, to gain access to the Athena's Fortune voyages. Then run the "Athenaās Run of Thieves" voyages - these are long (5 chapters!). Lots of treasure on each run - randomly some of them will be legendary. You'll probably have to do this voyage a few times to get them all though.
You purchased the 'Master Merchant' Promotion in the Merchant Alliance Trading Company.
You purchased the 'Master Merchant' Promotion in the Merchant Alliance Trading Company.
You completed 'Lords of the Sea'.
You completed 'Lords of the Sea'.
You completed all commendations for Heart of Fire
You completed all commendations for Heart of Fire
(Adventure) You sold all 5 Tomes of Curses.
(Adventure) You sold all 5 Tomes of Curses.
(Adventure) Completed the 'Stars of a Thief' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Completed the 'Stars of a Thief' Tall Tale.
Complete the "Stars of a Thief" tall tale - which you can begin at the North Star Seapost- by talking to Sudds.
You need to have already completed the Shroudbreaker.
Delivered every kind of cooked meat to The Hunter's Call.
Delivered every kind of cooked meat to The Hunter's Call.
(Adventure) Completed the 'Wild Rose' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Completed the 'Wild Rose' Tall Tale.
Madame Olive at the Sanctuary Outpost gives the book for this Tall Tale. Complete the Tall Tale!
(Arena) In The Arena, you took part in a contest using every single colour of ship.
(Arena) In The Arena, you took part in a contest using every single colour of ship.
You sailed in the same direction as a nearby ship without firing shots at each other.
You sailed in the same direction as a nearby ship without firing shots at each other.
(Adventure) You completed all Commendations for 'A Pirate's Life'.
(Adventure) You completed all Commendations for 'A Pirate's Life'.
You can't get all of the journals after placing the Cursed Captain on his final body in the captain's quarters - so don't do that until you've got everything or you'll have to restart the tall tale.
Completed 'The Art of the Trickster' Tall Tale.
Completed 'The Art of the Trickster' Tall Tale.
Complete this Tall Tale
You sold all 5 Tomes of Fire.
You sold all 5 Tomes of Fire.
You sold all 5 Tomes of Power.
You sold all 5 Tomes of Power.
(Adventure) Completed 'The Shores of Gold' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Completed 'The Shores of Gold' Tall Tale.
Complete this Tall Tale
(Adventure) Completed 'The Fate of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Completed 'The Fate of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
You killed a shark with a gunpowder keg
You killed a shark with a gunpowder keg
Kill a shark with a gunpower keg.
(Adventure) Completed the 'Revenge of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Completed the 'Revenge of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
Delivered a piece of treacherous loot to The Hunter's Call.
Delivered a piece of treacherous loot to The Hunter's Call.
You sailed through a storm with no lights during the night.
You sailed through a storm with no lights during the night.
(Arena) In The Arena, you delivered a stolen chest during a contest.
(Arena) In The Arena, you delivered a stolen chest during a contest.
Must be done in the arena; steal another crew's chest and deliver it.
Received the Commendation for delivering 25 Trophy Fish to The Hunter's Call.
Received the Commendation for delivering 25 Trophy Fish to The Hunter's Call.
(Adventure) You were promoted to level 75 with the Gold Hoarders.
(Adventure) You were promoted to level 75 with the Gold Hoarders.
(Adventure) You Defeated Captain Grimm 5 times
(Adventure) You Defeated Captain Grimm 5 times
(Adventure) You cleared the Fort of the Damned of all enemies, 10 times.
(Adventure) You cleared the Fort of the Damned of all enemies, 10 times.
You completed all Commendations for 'Captains of the Damned'.
You completed all Commendations for 'Captains of the Damned'.
(Adventure) You Defeated Old Horatio 5 times
(Adventure) You Defeated Old Horatio 5 times
You completed all Commendations for 'The Sunken Pearl'.
You completed all Commendations for 'The Sunken Pearl'.
(Adventure) You Defeated Warden Chi 5 times
(Adventure) You Defeated Warden Chi 5 times
(Adventure) You Defeated Red Ruth 5 times
(Adventure) You Defeated Red Ruth 5 times
You recovered 5 Revered Manifests while on Lost Shipment Voyages.
You recovered 5 Revered Manifests while on Lost Shipment Voyages.
You used a heavy attack to knock a member of another crew off of their ship.
You used a heavy attack to knock a member of another crew off of their ship.
(Adventure) You defeated the ghost of the Burning Blade 10 times!
(Adventure) You defeated the ghost of the Burning Blade 10 times!
Defeat Flamehearts ship 10 times.
(Adventure) You were promoted to level 75 with the Order of Souls.
(Adventure) You were promoted to level 75 with the Order of Souls.
You completed all Commendations for 'Dark Brethren'.
You completed all Commendations for 'Dark Brethren'.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Shroudbreaker' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Shroudbreaker' Tall Tale.
You were promoted to level 75 with the Merchant Alliance.
You were promoted to level 75 with the Merchant Alliance.
(Adventure) You completed all commendations for The Seabound Soul
(Adventure) You completed all commendations for The Seabound Soul
You completed all Commendations for 'Lords of the Sea'.
You completed all Commendations for 'Lords of the Sea'.
You purchased each type of Resource Crate and Commodity Crate from the Merchant Alliance.
You purchased each type of Resource Crate and Commodity Crate from the Merchant Alliance.
(Adventure) You were promoted to level 75 with the Reaper's Bones.
(Adventure) You were promoted to level 75 with the Reaper's Bones.
You were promoted to level 20 with Athena's Fortune.
You were promoted to level 20 with Athena's Fortune.
NB Athena's Fortune is only accessible once you reach Pirate Legend status.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Cursed Rogue' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Cursed Rogue' Tall Tale.
Completed all Commendations for the 'Sea of Thieves: A Pirate's Life' Tall Tales.
Completed all Commendations for the 'Sea of Thieves: A Pirate's Life' Tall Tales.
(Arena) In The Arena, you formed a crew of four and played your instruments during a contest.
(Arena) In The Arena, you formed a crew of four and played your instruments during a contest.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for the 'Wild Rose' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for the 'Wild Rose' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) You discovered the final message left behind by Glitterbeard.
(Adventure) You discovered the final message left behind by Glitterbeard.
(Adventure) You defeated 500 ghost ships!
(Adventure) You defeated 500 ghost ships!
(Adventure) You represented the Reaper's Bones in the Master Tier at the closure of an Emissary Ledger, 5 times.
(Adventure) You represented the Reaper's Bones in the Master Tier at the closure of an Emissary Ledger, 5 times.
You have to be in the Top ledger of this faction five times for five different months.
Received the Commendation for selling 360 Villainous Skulls.
Received the Commendation for selling 360 Villainous Skulls.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for purchasing 250 Cursed Captain Bounty contracts.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for purchasing 250 Cursed Captain Bounty contracts.
Grind this Order of Souls commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Legendary Storyteller' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Legendary Storyteller' Tall Tale.
Received all Commendations for the 'Stars of a Thief' Tall Tale.
Received all Commendations for the 'Stars of a Thief' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) You represented the Gold Hoarders in the Captain Tier at the closure of an Emissary Ledger, 5 times.
(Adventure) You represented the Gold Hoarders in the Captain Tier at the closure of an Emissary Ledger, 5 times.
You have to be in the Top ledger of this faction five times for five different months.
Received all Commendations for all the Shores of Gold Tall Tales.
Received all Commendations for all the Shores of Gold Tall Tales.
You threw vomit on an opposing pirate while they were wielding a sword.
You threw vomit on an opposing pirate while they were wielding a sword.
You'll need vomit in your bucket for this - so get drunk first (see What Shall We Do with a Drunken Sailor?) and catch the vomit in your bucket by equipping it as soon as you start vomiting.
With the bucket still equipped, find an opponent with their sword drawn and throw the bucket at them.
The opponent needs to be a human player, not a skeleton.
Received all Commendations for 'The Fate of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
Received all Commendations for 'The Fate of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Revenge of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Revenge of the Morningstar' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Art of the Trickster' Tall Tale.
(Adventure) Received all Commendations for 'The Art of the Trickster' Tall Tale.
Received the Commendation for selling 360 Captainās Chests.
Received the Commendation for selling 360 Captainās Chests.
In The Arena, you delivered a chest within the first five minutes of a contest.
In The Arena, you delivered a chest within the first five minutes of a contest.
In The Arena's tavern, you got at least one member of each crew into the hot tub at the same time.
In The Arena's tavern, you got at least one member of each crew into the hot tub at the same time.
(Adventure) You represented Athena's Fortune in the Legend Tier at the closure of an Emissary Ledger, 5 times.
(Adventure) You represented Athena's Fortune in the Legend Tier at the closure of an Emissary Ledger, 5 times.
You have to be in the Top ledger of this faction five times for five different months.
(Adventure) You represented the Order of Souls in the Grandee Tier at the closure of a Ledger, 5 times.
(Adventure) You represented the Order of Souls in the Grandee Tier at the closure of a Ledger, 5 times.
You have to be in the Top ledger of this faction five times for five different months.
(Adventure) Purchased the Master Hunter Promotion from The Hunter's Call Trading Company.
(Adventure) Purchased the Master Hunter Promotion from The Hunter's Call Trading Company.
You have to reach level 50 in the Hunters Call Faction.
(Adventure) You represented the Merchant Alliance in the Admiral Tier at the closure of a Ledger, 5 times.
(Adventure) You represented the Merchant Alliance in the Admiral Tier at the closure of a Ledger, 5 times.
You have to be in the Top ledger of this faction five times for five different months.
Received the Commendation for selling 300 Shipwrecked Chests.
Received the Commendation for selling 300 Shipwrecked Chests.
(Adventure) Delivered at least one of every kind of fish to The Hunter's Call.
(Adventure) Delivered at least one of every kind of fish to The Hunter's Call.
Sell every Fish in every color.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for purchasing 250 X Marks the Spot Voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for purchasing 250 X Marks the Spot Voyages.
Grind this Gold Hoarder commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 250 Order of Souls Voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 250 Order of Souls Voyages.
Grind this Order of Souls commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for sailing 1,000 nautical miles on Order of Souls Voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for sailing 1,000 nautical miles on Order of Souls Voyages.
Grind this Order of Souls commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for delivering 50 Fruit Crates on time.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for delivering 50 Fruit Crates on time.
Grind this Merchant Alliance commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 250 Gold Hoarder Voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 250 Gold Hoarder Voyages.
Grind this Gold Hoarder commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for defeating 1,000 Skeleton Captains.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for defeating 1,000 Skeleton Captains.
Skeleton Captains are the ones with their names in red - they appear after a few waves of regular skeletons.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for purchasing 250 Merchant Alliance contracts.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for purchasing 250 Merchant Alliance contracts.
Grind this Merchant Alliance commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for sailing 1,000 nautical miles on Gold Hoarder voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for sailing 1,000 nautical miles on Gold Hoarder voyages.
Grind this Gold Hoarder commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for delivering 100 Gunpowder Kegs on time.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for delivering 100 Gunpowder Kegs on time.
Grind this Merchant Alliance commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for sailing 1,000 nautical miles on Merchant Alliance Voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for sailing 1,000 nautical miles on Merchant Alliance Voyages.
Grind this Merchant Alliance commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 250 Merchant Alliance Voyages.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 250 Merchant Alliance Voyages.
Grind this Merchant Alliance commendation to level 5.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 57 Grade 5 Hunter's Call Commendations.
(Adventure) Received the Commendation for completing 57 Grade 5 Hunter's Call Commendations.
Complete every Commendation in Hunters Call.
(Adventure) While on Lost Shipment Voyages you located a missing ship along each of the Merchants' trade routes.
(Adventure) While on Lost Shipment Voyages you located a missing ship along each of the Merchants' trade routes.
(Arena) You gathered a total of 100,000 Silver from taking part in Arena Contests.
(Arena) You gathered a total of 100,000 Silver from taking part in Arena Contests.
(Arena) In The Arena, you delivered a chest during a contest - while drunk!
(Arena) In The Arena, you delivered a chest during a contest - while drunk!
(Arena) Received the Commendation for placing in the top three 100 times in The Arena.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for placing in the top three 100 times in The Arena.
In the Arena place in the top 3 in 100 contests.
(Adventure) You purchased the Glorious Sea Dog Jacket, Hat, Hook andĀ Gloves.
(Adventure) You purchased the Glorious Sea Dog Jacket, Hat, Hook andĀ Gloves.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for placing first 100 times in The Arena.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for placing first 100 times in The Arena.
You have to place first in 100 contests in the Arena.
(Arena) You purchased the Arena Master Promotion from the Sea Dogs Trading Company.
(Arena) You purchased the Arena Master Promotion from the Sea Dogs Trading Company.
You have to reach level 50 in the Sea Dogs Faction.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for placing first 100 times in The Arena as a Pirate Legend.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for placing first 100 times in The Arena as a Pirate Legend.
After you reached Pirate Legend, you have to place first in 100 contests in the Arena.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for completing 200 contests in The Arena.
(Arena) Received the Commendation for completing 200 contests in The Arena.
Just participate in 200 contests within The Arena.