Rosewater

The Journey Begins

Common54.2%

Set off across Western Vespuccia

Sneaky

Common49.8%

Picked Nadine's plan for the wagon raid

Heck of A Hangover

Common44.8%

Stop the bar brawl by smashing a bottle over the thug's head

Exorcised the Demons

Common42.2%

Successfully helped Captain Boylan

Heck of a Show

Common41.5%

Fully helped Miss Hatomi's troupe

Off the Mountain

Uncommon39.9%

Escaped New Bethel

Flor Silvestre

Uncommon39.7%

A campfire is always nicer with music

I Left My Heart in El Presidio

Uncommon39.6%

Arrive in El Presidio

Duck, You Sucker!

Uncommon38.4%

Knock Jem out

Once Upon A Time In Western Vespuccia

Uncommon36.0%

Complete the game

Tables Turned

Uncommon34.6%

Outsmart the scammer

Outsmarted the Trickster

Uncommon34.5%

Got the stick back from the coyote

In Rain, Sleet, or Snow...

Uncommon33.1%

Saved the post office

Loose-Lipped

Uncommon29.0%

Get the Fortuyn family to open up

Heroic

Uncommon26.9%

Save the kid at the river

Moving On

Uncommon24.8%

Help Danny with the memorial

Not in the Cards

Uncommon24.0%

Expose Lady Tyché's operation

The Last Traitor

Uncommon23.5%

Deal with Hernandez

Crackshot

Uncommon22.6%

Beat Marisol at shooting

Rough Justice

Uncommon21.1%

Enter the Jolly Good Club with Danny's help

Tradition Observer

Uncommon20.8%

Write something on the boulder

Oil's Well That Ends Well

Uncommon17.5%

Saved Cormac

Potion Master

Uncommon17.4%

Nadine helped get rid of the guard

Bullet Time

Uncommon16.8%

Danny helped get rid of the guard

Theatrical

Uncommon16.7%

Picked Jake's plan for the wagon raid

The Sign of the Coyote

Uncommon14.9%

Help the sick coyote

Straight and Narrow

Uncommon14.5%

Convinced Jem to give up his criminal ways

Dr. Redbird: Medicine Woman

Uncommon14.4%

Enter the Jolly Good Club with Nadine's help

Desperate Times

Uncommon12.8%

Pawned one of your companions' belongings

Gunslinger

Uncommon12.1%

Beat Marisol at shooting on your first try

Fish Story

Uncommon11.8%

Catch all the fish

Master Bluffer

Uncommon10.3%

Keep Jake's bluff going as long as possible

Say That Again

Rare9.9%

What a literal turn of mind you have

Good Listener

Rare8.7%

Let Martha handle Mr. Sirkas

Close Call

Rare8.5%

Phil disarmed the bomb

Ghost of a Chance

Rare7.4%

Phil helped get rid of the guard

Union Man

Rare7.2%

Enter the Jolly Good Club with Phil's help

Fossil Hunter

Rare6.1%

Successfully tagged 5 fossils

Teetotaler

Rare5.8%

Just said no

Initiate

Rare5.1%

Perform the labor union initiation correctly on your first try

Bloodthirsty

Very rare4.3%

Picked Phil's plan for the wagon raid

Cat Nap

Very rare3.8%

Drugged the wildcat

Tongue Twister

Very rare3.3%

You succeeded at Phil's challenge

Jokester

Very rare3.1%

Phil appreciates your sense of humor

Some Hard Feelings

Very rare2.8%

You punched Jake

Sharpshooter

Very rare2.7%

Beat Marisol at shooting on your first try...with a perfect score (and without practicing)

Buzzkill

Very rare2.3%

Got the bandits to leave by shooting the wasp nest

Master Hunter

Very rare1.9%

Shoot all the pheasants

A Fistful of Crowns

Very rare1.3%

Earned 200 crowns or more in one playthrough

Locksmith

Very rare1.3%

Pick every lock in the game in a single playthrough

Stargazer

Very rare1.3%

Correctly identify all constellations without any mistakes

Wily Coyote, Super Genius

Very rare1.3%

He's not very bright

The Magnificent Six

Ultra rare0.9%

Get all high relationship companion excursions in one playthrough