Rustler

Yellow Brick Road

Very common74.1%

Complete the first quest.

Multi-Level Manhandling

Uncommon20.5%

Complete all quests for the Loan Shark.

Blue Blood

Uncommon17.7%

Collect 5000 gold pieces and finish "Meat Muffins"

Black Sabbath

Uncommon17.4%

Complete all quests for the Priest.

The Last Crusade

Uncommon17.3%

Complete all quests for the Knights of the Holy Grail.

Groovy!

Uncommon11.2%

Set the amount of blood particles in settings to x5 and attack someone.

Weapon Master

Uncommon10.0%

Wield all weapons available in the game at least once.

Flat Enough

Rare9.3%

Complete all quests for the Spanish Inquisition.

The Ecstasy of Gold

Rare9.0%

Collect 20000 gold pieces.

Literally Stoned

Rare8.8%

Complete all quests for the Herbalist and the Doctor.

KILLUS MAGNUS

Rare8.4%

Kill 5 NPC in 5 seconds.

13th Century Schizoid Man

Rare7.8%

Complete all quests for Salazar.

Hail to the King!

Rare7.2%

Complete the main story line.

Call Me Conor

Rare6.3%

Win 10 fights in the MMA side activity.

The Forel Method

Rare5.9%

Block 10 attacks in 60 seconds.

Most Wanted

Very rare3.6%

Gain and then remove a maximum Wanted rating without dying and with no quest active.

One Guy Army

Very rare3.4%

Survive for 5 minutes at maximum Wanted rating.

Cutthroat

Very rare3.3%

Kill 500 people.

Udder Chaos

Very rare2.8%

Kill an NPC with a cow.

Lowrider

Very rare2.6%

Use Pimp-A-Horse 20 times.

The Other Son of Man

Very rare2.2%

Herd a total of 50 NPCs to mass during the church herding side activity.

One Man's Junk Is Another Man's Treasure

Very rare2.1%

Collect all horseshoes.

Highway Star

Very rare1.9%

Come first in 10 races.

Invasion of the Body Snatchers

Very rare1.7%

Collect 20 bodies during the body collecting side activity.

Double, double toil and trouble

Very rare1.6%

Successfully complete the Halloween event.

Harvest Moon

Very rare1.6%

Plow the fields 10 times.

Gotta Catch 'Em All!

Very rare1.4%

Catch all horses for This Neigh Land.

One Life Guy

Very rare1.1%

Complete 100% of the game without dying nor getting caught even once.

The Crown

Very rare1.1%

Complete 100% of the game, including all quests, side activities, and obtaining every other achievement.