The Caribbean Sail

Find the bottom of the ocean

Common64.5%

Oh look! It's right where we left it

Gone but not forgotten

Common57.5%

They say a man's last words are his best remembered... They usually just say "Blargh" though

Nailed it!

Common47.2%

...but how did a hat get on a fish?

The Promised Land

Common43.9%

wait... This isn't the Willamette Valley

Courier

Uncommon32.7%

I've been looking for you. Got something I'm supposed to deliver...

Survivors all!

Uncommon29.5%

That wasn't so bad... for our first trip

You are a pirate!

Uncommon26.2%

Yar har fiddle-dee-dee

You caught 2000 lbs. of food

Uncommon20.2%

but you were only able to carry 200 lbs. back

Skin that smoke wagon and see what happens

Uncommon16.0%

Survive a mutiny without anyone being shot

The Wanderer and the Whale

Uncommon12.4%

Catch a gentle giant of the sea

Decked Out

Uncommon11.5%

Fully upgrade your ship

A round on us

Uncommon10.5%

Defend Nassau from the Spanish fleet

Treasure Hunter

Rare9.8%

Good to know you can follow simple instructions

Dice Master

Rare9.3%

Win a game of liars dice without losing any dice

I and my fleas

Rare8.2%

Carry the plague to Nassau

Wealthy Trader

Rare7.5%

Do you work for the East India Trading company?

The long haul

Rare6.3%

Should have crossed the pacific

Explorer

Rare6.2%

Visit every port

Achievement Unlocked

Rare6.1%

Unlock everything

I am the Captain now

Rare5.4%

Give pirates the power of flight

We're gonna need a bigger boat

Rare5.0%

Catch a bull shark

Nobility

Very rare4.1%

"Sir" is it?

Oh well

Very rare3.8%

I guess you've done the impossible

Reel it back

Very rare3.7%

Catch 100 fish with one harpoon

Bring the gospel to pirates

Very rare3.4%

I never said it would be easy

HARK!

Very rare3.3%

Receive the boon of Poseidon

Artificial Courage

Very rare2.8%

Win a battle while drunk as can be

The Transatlantic Sail

Very rare2.8%

Sail from New York to London in under 5 days and 14 hours beating the current world record - Purist mode only

A doubloon saved

Very rare2.0%

isn't worth very much, but you're too good for shopping

Hypocrite.

Very rare1.6%

You did the Devils bidding, priest.

Shantyman

Very rare1.4%

Collect every shanty

Performing man

Very rare1.1%

You impressed the great Walrus

Divine Intervention

Very rare1.0%

Defeat a ship using the Raft

Master of the Seas

Ultra rare0.6%

You achieved every achievement in The Caribbean Sail